Publications 07/04/2022

Experiment with “orange” card in rugby

The proposed orange card is a measure that could change many things in the world of rugby. An experiment is underway in the southern hemisphere to replace the permanent exclusion of a red-carded player with a temporary exclusion of 20 minutes followed by a replacement player.

This measure would undoubtedly have a significant effect on the outcome of matches. Take, for example, the Champions Cup Round of 16 loss by Toulouse in the first leg against Ulster. Toulouse’s winger, Juan Cruz Mallia, was given a red card for careless but unintentional contact with a player whose feet were off the ground. (He was represented before the Disciplinary Commission by our sports law partner, Neil Robertson.) There can be little doubt that the result of the match would have been different when you consider that Toulouse only lost 20-26 after playing 70 minutes with 14…

The reasons put forward by World Rugby in favour of its new rule are the following: unwillingness to penalise the whole team, the safeguarding of a balanced game, or the denunciation of certain red cards that are judged too severe.

Nevertheless, this measure raises questions in a sport that seems to have been aware for several years now of the need to protect players’ health (especially concussions, whose long-term effects are a cause for concern). This has led to a tightening of sanctions with the more frequent use of the red card and greater disciplinary sanctions.

For example, World Rugby’s Disciplinary Regulations have for some years imposed a minimum medium grade entry point for any act of play deemed to be unfair that results in contact with the head or neck. Thus, a dangerous tackle with contact to the head will automatically result in a suspension of at least six weeks.

Recently, World Rugby even announced that it would impose mandatory rest periods for concussed players (see our article published this month, “World Rugby introduces mandatory multi-day rest for concussed players”).

Opponents of the new experiment have criticized the inconsistency and the contradictory signal sent to players, as well as the risk of an increase in dangerous behaviour that this would entail.

Is it more important to promote spectacular play or to safeguard the health of the players? For the time being, this measure divides the northern hemisphere.

Some, such as Jeremy Davidson (manager of CA Brive), call for a distinction to be made according to the seriousness of the action sanctioned: such as retaining the permanent exclusion for truly dangerous behaviour and introduce a temporary exclusion of twenty minutes for significant but less dangerous offences. The emergence of the “orange card”?

However, this compromise solution raises new difficulties, starting with distinguishing between what deserves a permanent exclusion and what deserves only a temporary one. This is an additional difficulty, given that rugby rules are often criticised for being too complex.

The team

Portrait de  Djezri

Meriem
Djezri

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Duffau

Juliette
Duffau

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Le Bras

Jeanne
Le Bras

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Michelet

Lola
Michelet

Paralegal

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Guntz

Léon
Guntz

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Bosco

Valentin
Bosco

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Karacam

Derya
Karacam

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Fischer

Adrien
Fischer

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Dhaou

Ilias
Dhaou

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Defudes

Jean-François
Defudes

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Bras

Louise
Bras

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Pinabiaux

Gauthier
Pinabiaux

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Coeur

Alexandra
Coeur

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Serant

Tessa
Serant

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Racé

Amandine
Racé

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Tourin

Geoffroy
Tourin

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Villain

Lucas
Villain

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Mouret

Mathilde
Mouret

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Mottier Mugnier

Julie
Mottier Mugnier

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Gonod

Hanna
Gonod

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Lavergne

Lucie
Lavergne

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  De Ruyffelaere

Emilie
De Ruyffelaere

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Fournier Lesvenan

Pauline
Fournier Lesvenan

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Delorme

Léa
Delorme

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Messmer

Elisa
Messmer

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Ollagnon

Marine
Ollagnon

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Douillard

Guillaume
Douillard

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Camille

Paul
Camille

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Desplancke

Clémence
Desplancke

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Diriart

Marie-Charlotte
Diriart

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Ollier

Nadège
Ollier

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Matouk

Mounira
Matouk

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Fokapu

Isabelle
Fokapu

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Nogris

Thomas
Nogris

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Brault-Scaillet

Virginie
Brault-Scaillet

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Stoop

Victoria
Stoop

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Bultel

Matthieu
Bultel

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Thoor

Charles-Eric
Thoor

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Nazaret

Tanguy
Nazaret

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Cazaux

Caroline
Cazaux

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Keraval

Quentin
Keraval

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  De Limairac

Edouard
De Limairac

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Nowak

Delphine
Nowak

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Devidal

Rachel
Devidal

Counsel

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Granotier

Jérôme
Granotier

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Morisse

Adrien
Morisse

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Bizet

Mathieu
Bizet

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Jourdain

Lise-Aure
Jourdain

Counsel

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Larivière

Philippe
Larivière

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Nadelgaft

Dimitri
Nadelgaft

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Vibert

François
Vibert

Counsel

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Boublil

Jérémie
Boublil

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Bauw

Alice
Bauw

Paralegal

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Moisy

Laurence
Moisy

Paralegal

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Tocchio

Jean-Marie
Tocchio

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Delmotte

Marie
Delmotte

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Wartelle

Martin
Wartelle

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Brisset

Paul
Brisset

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Mourot

Benjamin
Mourot

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Vamour

Alain
Vamour

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Brouard

Victor
Brouard

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Rastorgoueff

Serge
Rastorgoueff

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Lecat

Julien
Lecat

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Pinot

Sébastien
Pinot

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Mabed

Taous
Mabed

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Ghesquière

Alexandre
Ghesquière

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Vallet

Louis
Vallet

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Langer

Justine
Langer

Counsel

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Frantzen-Bourez

Sophie
Frantzen-Bourez

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Robertson

Neil
Robertson

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Moreau

Nicolas
Moreau

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Gohaud

Axel
Gohaud

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Benoit

Laetitia
Benoit

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Hyest

Félicien
Hyest

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Bertholet

Barbara
Bertholet

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Prévoteau

Ondine
Prévoteau

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Charron

Martin
Charron

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Dubly

Tanguy
Dubly

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Vignalou

François
Vignalou

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Bueche

Audrey
Bueche

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Scherrer

Pierre-Emmanuel
Scherrer

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Arminjon

Antoine
Arminjon

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Benoit

Antoine
Benoit

Partner

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Durupt

Adèle
Durupt

Senior associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Bertrand

Louis
Bertrand

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Clouye

Mathias
Clouye

Associate

Lire la suite
Portrait de  Coulon

Frédéric
Coulon

Partner

Lire la suite